During the ongoing frenzy
surrounding some American judicial appointment which struck me as Political
Porn—and it was Political Porn in the true, etymological sense given that
“Pornography” was once used to describe the writing about prostitution which has
also been defined as “the unworthy or corrupt use of one's talents for personal or
financial gain.”—I
thought on ways to get out of the quagmire that social/political debate has
become.
And in that I had to
consider those who line up on either side of the political/social/gender
divides. Those whose heartfelt conviction end up being little more than
gasoline on a fire that I believe has been lit to distract us from the more
nefarious activities of those who really shape our world. And that is not to detract
from the validity of those statements and arguments. But they are just that:
deeply held convictions about what should be right and what should be
normalized.
What concerns me more
about all of this is the widening of the divides between people who have far
more in common than their “Masters” would want them to realize.
Central to this current
“discussion” is whether or not a man can impose himself on a woman with
impunity, and if that woman takes so long in coming forward with her
allegations, can they be trusted. Never mind all the chatter about the Clintons
and the far-left; they are just there to inflame and distract.
My observations on life,
be it what I have seen, heard, or read, would say that not only can someone do
that but, if they have the necessary influence, they can get away with it and
leave their accuser with insult on top of injury.
However, to claim this is
a “Man versus Woman” issue is a contortion and one that is contradicted by the
number of women who, because of political alignment, publicly support the
particular man in this situation. It also discounts the less highlighted issues
of the rape of men which happens whether we want to believe it or not.
“Rape,” which was once
defined as "to snatch, to grab, to carry off" and was usually
accompanied by “Pillage,” is a much wider issue than the matter of sexual
violence. It
points to the underlying attitudes that are shared by Patrimonies,
Aristocracies, Religions, and all those other gatherings of the powerful.
Without minimizing the
brutal and dehumanizing impact of rape in the sexual term, considering it as a
tool of power should make it easier for more people to galvanize against it.
The current view that only men rape—and that other men condone it—serves only
to divide and make conquerable.
However, the suggestion
that there is a rape culture is impossible to ignore. Not only that, but it is
endorsed and enshrined in many of the Bronze Age texts that many claim are the
word of their god. Even the Greek Pantheon celebrated the sexual violence of
their gods.
From the beginning, rape
and pillage, have been central to the way we treat each other, the other life
forms we share the planet with, and even the planet itself—Capitalism being the
current glorification of snatching, grabbing, and carrying off.
It is central to how we
see ourselves and it is, to my mind, the crux of the problem that we must
address if we are to avoid the disastrous future we are all hurtling towards.
Rape and pillage have been the cornerstones on which our empires have been
built—even unto this day. The subjection of others for the sake of our sacred
creeds and manifestos is rape and pillage. The extreme behavior of drunken
“boys being boys” is rape and pillage, as is regime change, exploitation,
genocide and all the things we endorse our governments to do on our behalf.
The use of force can be
expeditious and more profitable, but we have often been warned that what goes
around, comes around. We cannot go on endorsing, by consent or disinterest,
the widespread use of violence against women, children, men, and then vent our
outrage when it is turned on us. We cannot go on celebrating those who use any
form of power and force as a weapon.
We cannot go on arguing
along political/social/gender lines. We cannot go on venting our outrage and
adding to the bonfires lit to distract us. We cannot go dividing ourselves as
“Left” or “Right,” “Male” or “Female.” That only leads to division and a weakening
of whatever influence we might have. And switching the “brand” of our political
representation may not be enough.
We must condemn all “Rape
and Pillage.”